How Steven Spielberg’s Unmade R-Rated Alien Horror Movie Night Skies Gave Birth to E.T., Poltergeist, and Gremlins

In the late 1970s and early 1980s, Steven Spielberg was deeply immersed in the development of a major motion picture project that ultimately would never see the light of day. Yet, when viewed through a broader cinematic lens, that phantom film did indeed get made—it was simply fractured, reconfigured, and scattered across a handful of other, remarkably famous films. We are talking about the holiday-horror hybrid Gremlins, the suburban supernatural haunting of Poltergeist, and, most famously, the heartwarming sci-fi masterpiece E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial.

This lost creative chapter is the subject of Stranded on Earth: How Night Skies Became E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial, a new book by movie journalist and author Max Evry.

"It was a dream team of people working on this thing," Evry explains, discussing the abandoned project known as Night Skies. "It was going to be a horror movie about these evil aliens, or mischievous aliens, that come to this rural farmstead and really mess with this family—they really fuck with this family."

Describing Night Skies as a dream team is hardly an exaggeration. The project boasted Steven Spielberg as producer, a script penned by acclaimed writer John Sayles, and production illustrator Ron Cobb slated to make his feature directorial debut. Furthermore, creature design was placed in the hands of visionary makeup effects master Rick Baker. Kathleen Kennedy was also firmly onboard, having worked closely with Spielberg at that stage of her career—an association that would soon culminate in her receiving her very first full producer credit on E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial.

Evry, who is also known for authoring the popular 2020 behind-the-scenes book A Masterpiece in Disarray: David Lynch’s Dune, spent considerable time investigating how Night Skies mutated from a terrifying, R-rated alien home-invasion thriller into the family-friendly box-office juggernaut that redefined modern cinema. He also traced how companion projects like Poltergeist and Gremlins were born concurrently from the same creative soil, summarizing his book as “a hard R-rated book about a children’s movie.”

From Close Encounters to a “Famous Clusterfuck”… and Ultimately E.T.

Stranded on Earth establishes its narrative foundation by looking back at Spielberg’s earliest adolescent filmmaking endeavors. Among these was Firelight, a micro-budget feature that the teenage Spielberg made for just $500. Miraculously, the film managed to secure a one-night theatrical screening in his hometown—a moment that Spielberg later recreated in his semi-autobiographical 2022 film, The Fabelmans. This juvenile epic served as an early indicator of the director’s lifelong fascination with unidentified flying objects and extraterrestrial life.

Before Directing the Biggest Success of His Career, Steven Spielberg Almost Made an Alien Horror Movie

"We’re dealing with Spielberg, we’re dealing with aliens, so we got to go all the way back to when he was 15, 16, making his first sort of feature film," Evry notes. "It was like this two-hour epic that he made when he was a teenager, and that story is really fun. It sets up the way that Spielberg deals with aliens throughout his career, because it’s like Martin Scorsese and gangsters. Spielberg has used aliens as a vessel for whatever kind of creative mood he happens to be in. I don’t believe—and there are many people who corroborate this in the book—he has a firm belief one way or the other about alien visitations and things like that. I think it’s just a great tool that he uses to explore different subjects."

Following his monumental success with 1977’s Close Encounters of the Third Kind, studio executives naturally anticipated a direct sequel. Instead, Spielberg leaned into concepts that would eventually steer him toward Night Skies.

"They spent close to a million dollars developing this thing," Evry says of the aborted film. "Some people in the book described it as kind of a weird science experiment, like maybe it’ll go, maybe it won’t. But it was heavily developed, and I think would’ve been a great movie."

This development period coincided with a turbulent era in Spielberg’s professional life. His ambitious, big-budget World War II comedy 1941, featuring an ensemble cast led by John Belushi, arrived in theaters in 1979 to a bruising reception. Evry characterizes the production as "a famous clusterfuck… a nightmare production where he was essentially going crazy with this thing, and it just kept getting bigger and bigger and bigger." The film’s commercial and critical stumbles severely damaged Spielberg’s industry standing, temporarily stripping away his aura of invulnerability.

The fallout from 1941 directly influenced how Hollywood perceived Night Skies and its subsequent evolution into E.T.. "There were a lot of people who thought he might be done," Evry observes. "So even after this project evolved from Night Skies to E.T., it became almost like this nuclear football where Columbia had it and then they just decided they didn’t want it and they gave it to Universal. Universal was kind of like, ‘Eh. We’ll do it, but you have to raise the money through a bond company. We don’t want to directly fund it because we don’t want to be responsible if you go over budget again.’ It was this interesting period where it was like the last time people didn’t trust Steven Spielberg."

Evolution of an Idea, From Aliens to Ghosts to Gremlins

While Spielberg served as the primary creative force behind Night Skies, he was never intended to direct the picture himself. During this window, he increasingly stepped into a producer role for emerging filmmakers, helping launch Robert Zemeckis’s early features I Wanna Hand Your Hand (1978) and Used Cars (1980). Zemeckis and his frequent writing partner Bob Gale also penned an unproduced script for Spielberg titled After School.

According to Evry, that script contained numerous narrative beats that ultimately migrated into the DNA of E.T.. "So it’s not just Night Skies. It was sort of [Spielberg] blending After School with Night Skies, and that’s how you get E.T."

Before Directing the Biggest Success of His Career, Steven Spielberg Almost Made an Alien Horror Movie

Before those pieces fell together, Ron Cobb was poised to make his directorial debut with Night Skies. Misconceptions have occasionally circulated suggesting that the directing job was a contest between Cobb and Tobe Hooper, but Evry clarifies that Hooper’s involvement came much later. Cobb had traveled to Spain to work as the production designer on Conan the Barbarian and was unable to return. With Rick Baker already producing storyboards, Spielberg reached out to Hooper. While Hooper declined the alien project, he expressed interest in making a horror film about ghosts instead—a conversation that birthed Poltergeist.

Despite their shared cinematic lineage, Evry points out that Night Skies and Poltergeist were actually developed in parallel. Both stories focused on a nuclear family—a mother, father, and three children spanning a range of ages—plagued by an outside, malevolent force invading their domestic sanctuary. In one narrative, the intruders were extraterrestrial visitors; in the other, supernatural specters. Even some explicit dialogue from the Night Skies drafts, most notably the chilling line "They’re here…", migrated directly into Poltergeist.

Meanwhile, Gremlins absorbed an even heavier dose of the original Night Skies lore. Although Gremlins originated as a spec script by Chris Columbus, John Sayles—the primary architect behind the Night Skies screenplay—subsequently boarded the project as a ghostwriter.

The conceptual roots of Night Skies trace back to a famous, deeply entrenched piece of American UFO folklore known as the Kelly-Hopkinsville encounter of 1955, in which a rural Kentucky family claimed their farmhouse was besieged by small, aggressive creatures. Evry dedicated a chapter of his book to the incident, visiting Hopkinsville firsthand during his research. That historical event helped popularize the cultural archetype of "little green men"—a phrasing explicitly echoed by characters toward the end of Gremlins.

"If you look at the actual eyewitness drawings of the aliens from Kelly-Hopkinsville, they look a hell of a lot like the Gremlins," Evry notes.

A Painful Memory

For Evry, interviewing legendary makeup and creature effects artist Rick Baker was a centerpiece of his research, though the subject stirred up deeply painful memories for the Oscar-winning artisan. While collaborators like John Sayles and Ron Cobb emerged from the collapsed project unscathed, Baker endured a severe and dramatic falling out with Spielberg that left lasting emotional scars.

"In some ways, he’s the central figure and it’s the most dramatic element of the book," Evry says. "John Sayles and Ron Cobb, they both came out of it just fine. But for Rick, it was a really tough experience, which we talk about—for whatever reason, he and Spielberg just had this tremendous falling out, very dramatic. And it was a trauma for him. And it’s like, I never wanted to portray seven-time Oscar winner Rick Baker as some kind of victim, but the thing you have to remember is at that time he was zero-Oscar winner Rick Baker. He was still kind of new to the business."

Before Directing the Biggest Success of His Career, Steven Spielberg Almost Made an Alien Horror Movie

Spielberg’s recollection of the parting of ways differs slightly from Baker’s account. Evry notes that in a previous publication regarding E.T., Spielberg recalled the separation as a mutual decision, a framing that Baker’s candid recollections and contemporaneous studio staff strongly dispute.

At the time, Baker was juggling his groundbreaking creature work on John Landis’s An American Werewolf in London. Evry argues that Baker’s contributions to Night Skies were equally revolutionary, noting that he uncovered original VHS footage of Baker’s alien test submissions to Spielberg. The creature designs demonstrated an expressive, versatile capability that would hold up remarkably against modern standards, easily outstripping contemporary makeup effects from 1980.

To navigate these conflicting recollections, Evry structured Stranded on Earth with a Rashomon-style approach, dedicating distinct chapters to Sayles, Cobb, and Baker to examine the tumultuous history from multiple viewpoints.

Ultimately, the unifying constant was Spielberg’s creative pivot—a sudden, intuitive realization that the terrifying alien home invasion narrative could be transformed into something profoundly tender and resonant.

"Spielberg has this intuitive creativity where he just said, ‘You know what? I think I can do something else with this,’" Evry concludes. "I’m really excited for horror fans, science fiction fans, but especially Spielberg fans to come away from this book with just a totally different perspective on what E.T. is, on what it could have been, and on what came after."

Raul Delapena Setiawan

Raul Delapena Setiawan

Content editor and sustainable journalism contributor at GenerateGreen.